How we rate

Every product gets 0 to 100 points. The rating follows fixed rules and is the same for every product. This is how it comes about.

The colours

The principle

The active ingredient sets the limit; the additives decide the points below it.

Points are only given for what the manufacturer controls: which additives it uses, which form of a vitamin or mineral it chooses and how precisely it describes its product. What lies in the substance itself – such as a warning from an authority or thin evidence – earns no points but can cap the score.

Additives · 40 points

Every additive and every other ingredient has a grade. For each grade we deduct points from the 40: harmless 0, unclear evidence 0 (information only), risk notice 10, of concern 20. No more than 40 points can be deducted.

We first look at what the authorities say (EFSA, BfR) and then at what independent studies show. A substance is “of concern” only with an official statement or if its authorisation was withdrawn. It gets a “risk notice” if an authority has raised concerns, EFSA reports that adults or the population in general, or users of food supplements, may exceed the permitted daily intake (ADI), or several consistent studies in humans show something adverse at usual amounts – even if it is authorised. If an exceedance only concerns children, only a calculation with the maximum permitted amounts, or EFSA itself considers its estimate too high, the substance has “unclear evidence”, and the reasoning names the group. A single finding, a finding only at high but achievable amounts, an association from an observational study or a result from animal or laboratory experiments is a hint, not proof: then the substance has “unclear evidence”, and the reasoning names the study and the amount. The reasoning always gives both sides.

How much of an additive is in a product isn't stated on the label. That is why we usually rate the substance, not the amount. Exception: for ingredients such as sugar, sugar alcohols or coconut oil, the position decides – they only count against the product if they are among the first three ingredients besides the active ingredients. A finding that only occurs at amounts practically never reached through food or supplements results in “harmless” with a note; the same applies to rare allergies. We do not downgrade mandatory allergens such as milk or soy; if you avoid them, you see them via “What I avoid”. An additive listed more than once only counts once. Ingredients called “… flavour” or “… flavouring” are rated together as flavouring. If older manufacturer information lists a substance that is no longer authorised in the EU (titanium dioxide), we don't rate it but ask for a current photo of the label.

Form, extract and strain details · 35 points

For vitamins, minerals, omega-3 and protein: how well does the body absorb the compound used, according to studies, and how well is it tolerated? The grades give 35 (very good), 25 (good), 11 (fair) or 0 points (poor). Magnesium citrate, for example, scores better than magnesium oxide.

If there are no independent studies on a form (“unclear evidence”), we do not count it against the product: if it is the only form of an active ingredient, that ingredient is left out of this criterion. If it appears alongside other forms, it counts with a middle value of 17 points, because we don't know its share.

If the label lists several forms without individual amounts, the first one counts most. Ingredients must be listed by weight, so the first is usually the largest.

For plant extracts: how precisely does the label describe the extract? Marker compound with amount 35 points, plant part and extract ratio 25, just “extract” 12. Plain plant powders do not count here. This only counts if the label itself says “extract”. A “concentrate” only counts as an extract if a content, a percentage or “standardised” is stated.

For bacterial cultures: strains with designation and count 35 points, only one of the two 25, just “lactic acid bacteria” 12.

For substances without different forms, such as creatine or amino acids, this criterion doesn't count. The score then comes from the remaining criteria.

Transparency · 15 points

Are the amounts and forms of the active ingredients on the label? For each active ingredient, the amount counts 60 % and the form 40 %. If we simply couldn't read a detail, it doesn't count against the product; it only costs points once it is clear that it really isn't on the label.

If the manufacturer only gives the total amount of a blend without the individual amounts (“proprietary blend”), this criterion gets at most 5 of 15 points. Each umbrella term such as “herbal extract” or “plant blend”, which hides what exactly is inside, costs 3 points.

Quality evidence · 10 points

Laboratory analyses and certificates from independent bodies, for example the Cologne List. A laboratory analysis earns 6 points, a certificate 4. A self-declaration such as “lab-tested” does not count, and we only take a laboratory analysis from the manufacturer's information, never from users. If we know of no evidence for a product, this criterion is left out. It can never lower the score.

How the points become the score

We add up the points of the criteria that apply to a product and scale them up to 100. Criteria that don’t apply, or about which we know nothing, are left out – they make the score neither better nor worse. Which criteria are left out for a product is shown with the result under “Rating in detail”.

Example: a creatine powder has no different forms, and we know of no proof of quality. So only additives (40) and transparency (15) count. If it gets 36 and 15 points, that’s 51 of 55 possible – scaled up, 93.

We calculate proof of quality once with and once without; the higher value counts. So proof can only improve the score.

The dose: a safety check

The dose earns no points. We show the daily amount according to the recommended intake and, next to it, the official values with their source, for example the BfR proposed maximum level (DE) or EFSA's recommendation. We don't recommend a dose of our own.

What counts for the score? EFSA's recommendation: EFSA reviews the evidence and recommends not taking more than this amount per day from all sources combined, because below it no harm is expected. We treat in the same way an amount up to which EFSA explicitly sees no concern (for example 15 mg beta-carotene) and a legal EU maximum (for example for EGCG from green tea extract). The BfR proposed maximum level (DE) is additional information for us and costs no points: the BfR subtracts what people already get from food and assumes that someone may take several products at once. Its value for a single supplement is therefore deliberately cautious, for vitamin D for example 20 µg instead of 100 µg.

Our basis is the EFSA values and the German BfR values. Other countries may have different non-binding recommendations or binding maximum levels.

If the daily amount is above this value, the score is capped (see “Caps”). Where exceeding it has only mild effects, as with magnesium, we grade it: up to 1.5 times just a note, up to double at most 74, beyond that at most 49.

For some substances EFSA gives no recommendation, but an authority names an explicit value: for piperine the German BfR names a safety value for food supplements; for PQQ, AstraGin, citicoline, nicotinamide riboside and synthetic zeaxanthin the EU authorisation sets a legal maximum amount. Above it the score is capped at 74.

If the amount is very low (below 15 % of the reference value or below the amount of an authorised health claim), this is shown as a note only. It costs no points.

How we determine the daily amount: if the recommended intake gives a range (“1–3 capsules”), we check the highest amount and say so. If a product is only taken “every other day” or “per week”, we convert it to a daily amount. For extracts, the content stated on the label counts (“of which 8 mg astaxanthin”), not the weight of the extract. If a mineral is only given as the weight of the compound (“zinc bisglycinate 125 mg”), the amount of the mineral is unknown; we don't calculate it ourselves. If a value applies only to a particular form (such as nicotinic acid for niacin), we use that value. Amounts so high that they cannot be right (usually mg instead of µg) are not rated, and the result says so.

Caps

A clear weakness shouldn't disappear in the average. In these cases the score is capped, and the reason is stated with the result:

Why there are caps: an average can hide a clear weakness. A product with very good additives but a daily amount above the EFSA value could otherwise easily score over 80. The caps 49 and 74 are the upper ends of the colour levels: a red weakness allows orange at most, an orange one light green at most.

At most 49 – a red weakness:

At most 74 – an orange weakness:

If something is missing, we do not cap the score but give no overall score at all: when an active ingredient, a stated form or an additive is not yet in our database, or the ingredient list is missing. The result then says “Rating to follow” (see below).

The evidence

For each active ingredient we show which studies exist. The grade names say what they refer to: “EU health claim or several independent studies”, “at least one independent study”, “independent studies show no benefit”, “only manufacturer studies” or “no study on this substance”. “At least one independent study” requires at least one randomised controlled trial in humans that was not run or paid for solely by the maker of the ingredient. If there are only studies by the maker, the grade is “only manufacturer studies”; if there is no controlled study on exactly this substance, or only studies on mixtures, it is “no study on this substance”. If the manufacturer only supplied the product for a study, without paying for it or having its own employees as authors, it counts as independent; the reasoning always says so. If independent controlled trials contradict each other, the majority decides: if most show no benefit, the grade is “independent studies show no benefit”. Small studies count too; the reasoning always states how many people took part. There are also two neutral grades: “produced by the body” for substances the body makes itself, and “food” for ordinary foods. The evidence gives no points. It can, however, cap the score (see “Caps”).

What effect a substance has, we only state in the wording of the health claims authorised in the EU.

Rating to follow, provisional, vague, unclear

“Rating to follow” means an active ingredient, a stated form or an additive is not yet in our database, or the ingredient list is missing. We then give no overall score. What we already know is shown individually with its grade. We never estimate.

There is also no overall score if we can't identify an active ingredient, if details about a product contradict each other or it is unclear which variety a barcode belongs to (“details unclear”), or if a product contains a substance that counts as a medicinal substance or hormone in the EU (for example DHEA or pregnenolone). The reason is shown with the result.

“Provisional” means an amount is missing. The score is still calculated and is not capped for this reason – nothing speaks against the product. A photo of the label can close the gap.

“Too vague” means the label only gives an umbrella term. This costs 3 points for transparency.

“Unclear evidence” means there are indications from observational studies, animal or laboratory studies or open questions, but no evidence in humans. We show this for information, with reasoning and source, and deduct no points for it (for forms, see above).

Where the grades come from

The ingredients are read from the label with artificial intelligence. The rating is not made by artificial intelligence: it comes from fixed rules and a knowledge base in which every grade has a source and was approved by a person. You can open the sources for every substance.

Independent

Agaset is independent: we receive no payments, commissions or benefits in kind from manufacturers or retailers. There are no paid ratings, placements or highlights, no affiliate links, no free products for testing and no discounts. We show no third-party advertising. No manufacturer has a stake in Agaset. The app is funded solely by Premium subscriptions from our users.

Where the values come from

Next to the daily amount we show official values and who issued them. EFSA (the European Food Safety Authority) names, for many vitamins and minerals, an amount that should not be exceeded per day from all sources combined (tolerable upper intake level, UL); we call it “EFSA's recommendation”. EFSA recommends not taking more than this amount per day from all sources combined; below it, adverse health effects are very unlikely. The recommendation is not binding.

The BfR (German Federal Institute for Risk Assessment) derives proposed maximum levels for food supplements from it by subtracting the usual intake from food. Both are proposals: in Germany there are so far no binding maximum levels for vitamins and minerals in food supplements. Where a legal maximum exists, for example for EGCG from green tea extract, we call it that. For some novel foods the EU authorisation sets a maximum daily amount; we call it the “maximum amount under the EU authorisation”. A permitted daily intake (ADI) set by EFSA, for example for curcumin as a colour, is only shown. EFSA's recommendation for vitamin A only applies to preformed vitamin A, not to beta-carotene. Our basis is the EFSA values and the German BfR values. Other countries may have different non-binding recommendations or binding maximum levels.

Unless stated otherwise, the values apply to adults; the BfR proposals mostly to people aged 15 and over.

What this app is not

It rates the composition of products on the basis of published sources. It is not medical advice, makes no diagnoses and does not replace advice from a doctor.

Agaset rates the composition of products on the basis of published sources. This is not medical advice and does not replace advice from a doctor.